StatStuff is the only FREE source for complete Lean Six Sigma Training

  • Register
  • Login

The only FREE source for complete Lean Six Sigma training!

Dewey Defeats Truman

Written by 
(2 votes)

The real statistical story behind the "Dewey Defeats Truman" blunder from the Chicago Tribute headline.

Video Transcript

Have you ever seen this famous photo?  It's from the 1948 election where after election day, Harry Truman is holding up the Chicago Tribune that wrongly announced that the Republican candidate Dewey defeated him. But do you know why the Tribune got this wrong? 

Despite their headline blunder, the Tribune actually did a good job in their statistical analysis. They surveyed enough people to get a good sample size, they normalized the survey respondents with the right demographics across the US at that time, and they correctly analyzed the data they collected. So why were their conclusions so wrong? 

Since it was election night, they simply called people across the US to find out who they voted for. Makes sense, right? But what they didn't consider is that most people in the US didn't have telephones in 1948; they were mostly owned by wealthy people who tended to be Republican. So they unintentionally biased their data by primarily calling Republicans who naturally voted for Dewey, the Republican candidate.

So what can we learn from this? We already know it's important to have unbiased data, but we also need to consider HOW we collect that data . It doesn't matter how good we are at doing statistical analysis if we can't ensure the data we're analyzing is completely unbiased, including what method we use to collect that data.

Matt Hansen

Matt is a Lean Six Sigma Master Black Belt who has led and consulted on hundreds of continuous improvement initiatives for over 20 years across several industries such as Government (Dept. of Defense), Insurance, Telecommunications, Transportation, Finance, and Higher Education.  He has developed and led enterprise Lean Six Sigma Training and Mentoring Programs at two billion-dollar organizations and has been credited with influencing a continuous improvement culture across the organization. The savings from the projects he has led well exceed $120 Million.

For more details about Matt's experience, you can check out his profile and connect with him on LinkedIn.  If you'd like to use Matt for consulting or speaking engagements, please contact him here.


More in this category: « Galton Board
Login to post comments

Search the Dictionary of Lean Six Sigma Tools/Concepts

Search for dictionary terms (regular expression allowed)
Begin with Contains Exact termSounds like